"Electability" is a function of your opponent, too. That's bad news for Trump.
Voters are bearish that any Democrat can beat Trump yet still prefer most others to him
What even is “electability”?

The Takeaway: Even as I proof-read this text, I can tell that I sound like a broken record. But here goes: General election polls released this early are likely not predictive of the final 2020 vote share—but perhaps we can still learn something from them. Here’s what I see in the numbers: Donald Trump is deeply unpopular, faces a tough re-election battle, and performs roughly the same against different opponents.
Editor’s note:
Thanks for reading my thoughts on this subject. And thanks for subscribing! Your membership adds up and makes all this newslettering possible (reminder: I do all this work independently). Please consider sharing online or with a friend; the more readers, the merrier. Remember that apart from getting special articles subscribers can also comment below each post and participate in exclusive threads.
As always, send me your tips about what you’d like to read about next. Or what you don’t want to read. Or your feedback otherwise. Also, cat pictures are nice, so please send them to me! I’m elliott@thecrosstab.com, or @gelliottmorris on Twitter.
Thanks all,
—Elliott
According to the most recent polling from Fox News (the numbers come from a bipartisan team of researchers from Democratic polling house Beacon Research and Republican firm Shaw & Company Research), Donald Trump faces a steep uphill battle for re-election. The president trails Joe Biden in a hypothetical 2020 match-up by 12 percentage points (50-38%). He fares slightly better, but still poorly overall, against Bernie Sanders (48-39), Elizabeth Warren (46-39) and Kamala Harris (45-39).

But I’m not viewing these numbers as projections of behavior for the election next November (and neither should you). Instead, here’s the story:
Although Mr Trump’s general election deficit changes depending on his opponent, he is held below 40% in all polled match-ups against mainstream 2020 Democrats. This fact got me thinking: electability might be about the quality of one candidate, but it is equally (or perhaps even more) about the quality of their opponent. Although polling says that voters think Joe Biden is more “electable” than, say, Warren or Sanders, they still run far ahead of Trump when it comes to vote intention.


And here’s another point: it doesn’t actually matter which 2020 Democratic candidates we think are electable if their opponent is polling under 40% against all of them. The facts are the facts; the data are the data. The probability of victory for a Democrat polling 12 points ahead of Trump is only marginally higher than their probability of victory if they are 6 points ahead. If their opponent is polling below 40%, almost anyone could beat them.
So if our question is “who can beat Trump?” instead of “who has the highest probability of beating Trump?”—and usually I would caution against such binary thinking, but I think it’s apt here—perhaps the conversation about electability should not be about how Biden or Warren can fare in the general election, but about how Donald Trump will.